Resistance Burning Skies review round-up: Vita shooter divides critics

All the Resistance Burning Skies review scores in one place...

In our Resistance: Burning Skies review we said although the game isn't "a showcase for Vita's visual powers" it is "hard proof it can handle fully-fledged first-person shooters".

Resistance: Burning Skies is the PS Vita's premiere first-person shooter. Unlike its predecessor, the latest PlayStation handheld is more accommodating of the genre thanks to dual-sticks and numerous other hardware bells and whistles.

Developed by Nihilistic Software, no doubt with considerable guidance from Sony, Burning Skies should be a blueprint for how to do a shooter properly on the Vita. But if early reviews are any indication it might instead be a collection of hard lessons on the trails and tribulations of developing a shooter on the handheld.

Evidently the freshman shooter has proved itself to be very divisive amongst critics. We've collected up the first crop of reviews and stuck them below for your consideration. Have a look:


CVG: 7.9 - Not a showcase for Vita's visual powers, but hard proof it can handle fully-fledged first-person shooters - another solidly rousing slice of Resistance.
JustPushStart: 6.3 - Resistance: Burning Skies isn't quite on par with Uncharted: Golden Abyss, but it proves a FPS can work on a portable console. Despite this shortcoming, the Playstation Vita is perfect for FPS fans, though the genre has yet to be fully realized. With less than stunning graphics and a short campaign, Resistance: Burning Skies feels incomplete next to other games in the genre. However, if you're a diehard FPS fan, then you should definitely pick this game up.
VideoGamer: 6 - I wish Resistance: Burning Skies had been braver and bolder. It's the first fully-fledged FPS on the Vita, and it has all those brilliant guns, but it doesn't strut around like Vita's first-person saviour. It's a reserved, almost lazy attempt, and developer Nihilistic always opts for the safe bet. The shooting is top notch, but poor pacing and bland environments ensure you never engage with what's going on, and technical hiccups and formulaic game modes sour the multiplayer. This game proves the potential power of the genre on its device, but not the potential excellence of its own franchise.
PocketGamer: 7 - A conventional, by-the-numbers shooter that just about stands out for its enjoyable firefights, in both single and multiplayer, and for being the first handheld FPS to really work
ShopTo: Good - Resistance Burning Skies campaign has a decent enough story, provides a tough challenge and when that's done, players then have the option to either play again via New Game + or head online to shoot up some fellow Vita players. Resistance Burning Skies may not be perfect, but it's the only portable FPS experience out there for the Vita at the moment and that could be the only convincing that gamers need.
PS Nation: B - I had a hard time sticking with this one at the early stages, but I'm now glad that I did, as the last half of the game is very satisfying. As I cryptically posted on Twitter yesterday, "it gets better."
PlayStation Lifestyle: 8.5/10 - Resistance: Burning Skies it the total package for the PlayStation Vita. Insomniac's franchise is in good hands with Nihilistic, and they've done a respectable job in bringing the first twin-stick FPS game to a handheld. Vita's few remaining limitations are overcome with genius design. The single-player, while on the short side and lacking in replay value, is excellent. Gun play is grand, and multiplayer stacks up to many console shooters. If you have a Vita, and like the Resistance franchise or enjoy FPS, buy this game.
The Sixth Axis: 6/10 - Hardcore Resistance fans will no doubt like what Nihilistic have managed to get the Vita to do, but for everyone else this is little more than a competent, hard working game that ticks the right boxes but never really pushes the boat out. The graphics are hit and miss, the sound generally terrible and the controls need some work. But it's not a bad game, it's really not - and for the premier first person shooter on Vita it's likely to gain a decent enough following.
IGN: 5.5 - Resistance: Burning Skies has the honor of being the first true twin-stick FPS on a handheld, but it doesn't do much with it. The story here is forgettable, the action is formulaic, and the multiplayer is simplistic. If first-person action is your favorite thing in the world, Resistance: Burning Skies is at your service. Just don't expect it to shine like we know this franchise can.
GamesRadar: 4 - Resistance: Burning Skies doesn't offer the Resistance experience you'd expect, period. The weapon variety that defines the series is flaccid at best, the story is forgettable, and the multiplayer isn't even as varied as the last handheld game in the series. It's hard to even recommend this one to gamers who've spent the last six years popping Chimera skulls. Even if a few rounds of Survival are rather fun, there isn't enough unique content here to attract many people, be they long-time Resistance fans or folks looking to get their FPS jones from the Vita. Resist the temptation.
Destructoid: 2 - If, like me, you've been waiting to see how a first-person shooter feels on the Vita, then I can say that this game proves the potential of the genre. However, if you'd like your first Vita FPS to actually be good, then wait for something else, because Resistance: Burning Skies is far from acceptable. It is visually atrocious, interactively vapid and incomplete to a degree that a full retail price is an insult. It's tempting to buy this just to have something new on the system, but good things come to those that wait, and it's hard to imagine anything not being good compared to this mess.